The Honest Version
Most Advice on Hiring a Realtor Is Written by Realtors
Which means it’s usually generic, self-serving, and not particularly useful for someone buying or selling property in Southern Middle Tennessee specifically. This guide is different. I’m going to tell you exactly what to look for in this market — including the things that would disqualify me if I didn’t measure up to them.
Columbia and the surrounding counties are a specific market. Rural property here — farms, land, homes with acreage — has value drivers that most agents have never dealt with. Greenbelt enrollment, well and septic systems, timber value, creek access, agricultural use history. If your agent can’t speak to these things fluently, they’re guessing at your price and reaching the wrong buyers.
Here’s what to look for, what to ask, and what to walk away from.
What to Look For
5 Things That Actually Matter When Choosing a Realtor Here
They Actually Work in This Market
There are agents based in Nashville who list Columbia as part of a wide coverage area. That’s not the same as an agent who works Maury, Giles, Lawrence, Marshall, and Lewis Counties every week. Ask how many transactions they’ve closed in your specific county in the last 12 months. A vague answer tells you everything you need to know.
They Understand Rural Property Specifically
If your property has acreage, well water, septic, Greenbelt enrollment, outbuildings, or any agricultural use — your agent needs to understand all of it. Not just know the words, but be able to explain Greenbelt rollback to a buyer, price a working barn accurately, and know what a water quality test means for your closing timeline. Ask them to explain how they’d price your rural property differently than a subdivision home nearby.
They Have the Right Marketing for Rural Property
A subdivision home gets listed on the MLS and Zillow. A farm or hunting tract also needs to be on LandWatch, Land And Farm, and Lands of America — where the actual rural buyer pool searches. It needs drone footage. It needs a listing description that speaks to agricultural buyers, not general homebuyers. Ask specifically what platforms your listing will appear on and what marketing happens in the first two weeks.
They’re Reachable — Actually Reachable
Rural buyers don’t shop 9 to 5. Serious buyers call on evenings and weekends. If your agent doesn’t respond promptly during the interview process, they won’t respond promptly when a buyer is standing in your driveway with questions. How quickly they respond to your first inquiry is one of the most reliable signals you’ll get about how they’ll behave once you’re a client.
They’ll Let You Walk Away
A 6-month locked-in listing contract with early termination fees is a red flag. An agent who is confident in their work doesn’t need to trap you. Ask directly — what happens if I’m not satisfied after a few weeks? The answer tells you a lot about the relationship you’re about to enter. The best agents offer an easy exit because they don’t expect you to need it.
Interview Checklist
Questions to Ask Before You Hire Anyone
These are the questions that separate agents who know this market from agents who just cover it. Take notes. Compare answers.
How many transactions have you closed in Maury County — or the county my property is in — in the last 12 months?
A strong local agent answers this with a specific number. A general agent hedges with “Middle Tennessee” or “the Nashville metro.”
How do you price rural property differently than a residential home?
They should mention Greenbelt, water features, soil quality, outbuilding value, and comparable rural sales — not just price per square foot.
What platforms will my listing appear on beyond the MLS?
For rural and farm listings you need LandWatch, Land And Farm, and Lands of America. If they only mention Zillow and Realtor.com, they don’t know the rural buyer pool.
What is your average days on market compared to the area average?
An agent who prices and markets well sells faster. They should be able to answer this. If they can’t, they’re not tracking their performance.
Who specifically will handle my transaction — you or an assistant?
Some busy agents hand off day-to-day client communication to unlicensed assistants. Know upfront who you’re actually working with.
Can I cancel the listing agreement if I’m not satisfied?
The answer and the terms matter. An agent confident in their work will offer an easy out. An agent who hesitates is telling you something.
Red Flags
Walk Away If You See Any of These
These aren’t minor issues. Each one is a signal that the relationship is going to be frustrating at best and costly at worst.
They’re based in Nashville and “cover” Columbia
Coverage is not the same as knowledge. An agent who drives 45 minutes to show your property doesn’t know your neighborhood, your comps, or your buyer pool the way a local does.
They can’t explain Greenbelt or rural due diligence
If they can’t explain Greenbelt rollback, what a perc test is, or why a well inspection matters — they have not sold rural property in this market. These are basic fluency for this area.
They push you to list higher than the comps support
Overpricing to win the listing is one of the oldest tricks in the industry. They get the listing, then spend the next 90 days convincing you to reduce the price. The first two weeks are when motivated buyers are watching — you can’t get those back.
They’re slow to respond before you hire them
If it takes 24–48 hours to get a call back during the interview phase, that’s the best version of the communication you’ll experience. It only gets slower after you sign.
They lock you into a 6-month contract with penalty clauses
A long locked-in listing agreement with early termination fees signals that the agent isn’t confident you’ll stay voluntarily. The best agents don’t need to trap you.
Full Disclosure
How I Measure Up Against This List
You should hold me to every standard on this page. Here’s where I stand on each one — honestly.
I live and work in Columbia
I moved here from Chicago with my wife, who grew up in Tennessee. Columbia is my home. I work Maury, Giles, Lawrence, Marshall, and Lewis Counties specifically — not as part of a wider Nashville territory.
I know rural property specifically
I can explain Greenbelt rollback, what to look for in a well inspection, how to price timber, and why a perc test matters. I got into real estate because my own rural property purchase was full of surprises — I know what buyers and sellers need to understand going in.
I market on the right platforms
Every farm and land listing goes on LandWatch, Land And Farm, and Lands of America in addition to the MLS and Zillow. Drone footage on every acreage listing. Targeted digital ads reaching rural buyers by profile, not just zip code.
I respond same day — evenings and weekends included
Calls, texts, and emails. Rural buyers don’t shop 9 to 5 and neither do I. If you reach out, you’ll hear back the same day.
I offer the Easy Exit Listing
Cancel anytime. If it’s before 90 days you cover the marketing costs — typically $300–$500. After 90 days, walk away free and clear. I offer this because I’m confident you won’t need to use it. Learn more →
Common Questions
Realtor Questions, Answered
How do I choose the best realtor in Columbia TN?
The most
Put me to the test on every standard on this page. Start with a free valuation or a 15-minute call — no pressure, no pitch, no long-term commitment required upfront. Free — No Obligation
Find out what your property is worth before you decide anything. Real comparable sales, honest price range, response within 24 hours. No spam. No obligation. Or just send a message →
Ask me anything on this list. Pick a time below and let’s talk about your property and whether I’m the right fit.
Five stars across 6 Google reviews — real results from real people across Southern Middle Tennessee.
Ready to Talk to Chris?
Start With a Free Property Valuation
Schedule a Conversation
What Clients Are Saying